Why I’m Obsessed with the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese: My Go-To Creamy Eye Base

I’ve always believed that the right eye pencil can completely transform your makeup look, adding just the perfect pop of color or definition with minimal effort. Recently, I stumbled upon the Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese Color, and it quickly became a staple in my beauty routine. This creamy, versatile pencil isn’t just another eyeliner—it’s a game-changer for creating everything from subtle highlights to bold, creative looks. If you’re curious about what makes this shade and formula stand out, you’re in for a treat.

I Tried The Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil In Cottage Cheese Color Myself And Shared My Honest Thoughts

1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil – Cottage Cheese (Silver)

When I first came across the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in the shade Cottage Cheese (Silver), I was genuinely intrigued by its promise as a multi-functional product. This isn’t just any eyeliner; it’s a blendable eyeshadow stick and eyeliner pencil rolled into one, making it a versatile addition to anyone’s makeup kit. The idea of having a product that can serve as a creamy eyeshadow, eyeliner, and even a highlighter instantly appealed to me because it simplifies the makeup routine while offering creative flexibility. Whether you want to apply it on your waterlines, inner corners, or your entire lid, the intense pop of silver color it provides really stands out, perfect for those who love a radiant, eye-catching look.

What impressed me the most was how smooth and effortless the pencil glides on. There’s no pulling or tugging on the delicate skin around the eyes, which is a huge plus for me because comfort during application is just as important as the final look. The creamy texture also means it blends beautifully, allowing me to smudge it out for a smoky effect or layer it for more intensity. Plus, the fact that it’s available in a rainbow of vivid hues and multiple finishes—from matte to metallic—means there’s something for every mood or occasion. This particular silver shade, Cottage Cheese, offers a metallic shimmer that brightens up the eyes without feeling too harsh or overdone, making it suitable for both day and night looks.

Another aspect I really appreciate about NYX is their commitment to cruelty-free cosmetics. Knowing that this product is PETA-certified and not tested on animals adds an ethical dimension to my purchase decision. It feels good to support a brand that aligns with values I care about, and it’s reassuring to know I’m not compromising on quality or performance while making a compassionate choice. Beyond this pencil, NYX’s comprehensive range of eye makeup products—from eyeshadow palettes to eyelashes and primers—means I can easily complete and customize my entire eye look within one trusted brand.

To give you a clearer overview, here is a summary table highlighting the key benefits and features of the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese

Feature	Benefit to User
Multi-functional (Eyeshadow, Eyeliner, Highlighter)	Simplifies makeup routine; versatile usage for various eye looks
Creamy, Blendable Formula	Easy application without tugging; smooth blending for smoky or intense effects
Intense Silver Color (Cottage Cheese)	Adds radiant pop to eyes; suitable for day and night wear
Wide Range of Shades and Finishes	Offers customization and creativity for every style
Cruelty-Free Certification (PETA)	Ethical choice; no animal testing involved
Part of Comprehensive Eye Makeup Line	Easy to complete full eye look with complementary products

I find the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese to be a fantastic investment for anyone looking to add a high-quality, versatile, and ethically made product to their makeup arsenal. Its ease of use, striking color payoff, and multifunctional nature make it a standout choice that can elevate everyday eye makeup or glam up a special occasion. If you’re seeking a product that offers both performance and conscience, this pencil is well worth trying out. Personally, I feel confident recommending it and would consider it a smart buy for both beginners and makeup enthusiasts alike.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil Duo – Frosting (Champagne) & Cottage Cheese Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencils

When I first came across the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil Duo in Frosting (Champagne) & Cottage Cheese, I was immediately drawn to its multifunctional promise. This product isn’t just your average eye pencil—it’s a versatile tool that serves as an eyeliner, eyeshadow, and highlighter all in one. For someone like me who loves experimenting with eye looks but also values simplicity and efficiency, this jumbo pencil duo seemed perfect. The idea of having two radiant, blendable shades that can add a pop of intense color to my waterlines, inner corners, or full eyelids is incredibly appealing. It’s like having a mini eye makeup kit in a compact, travel-friendly form.

One of the standout features for me is the creamy texture that glides on smoothly without any tugging or pulling. This makes application effortless and comfortable, which is essential when dealing with delicate eye areas. I appreciate that the pencil can be used in so many ways—whether I want a subtle highlight or a bold eyeliner effect, this product adapts beautifully. The fact that it comes in shades like Frosting (Champagne) and Cottage Cheese means it’s easy to create soft, natural looks or add a shimmering glow that brightens the eyes. The versatility extends to finishes too, ranging from matte to metallic, which opens up even more creative possibilities.

What truly enhances the appeal of this duo is the commitment of NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP to cruelty-free cosmetics. Knowing that the brand is certified by PETA and does not test on animals adds a level of ethical satisfaction to my purchase. This aligns with my values and makes me feel good about supporting a brand that cares about animal welfare. Besides, NYX’s broad range of complementary eye makeup products like eyeshadow palettes, eyelashes, and setting sprays means I can easily build a complete eye look with products I trust and love.

To give you a clearer picture, here’s a breakdown of the key aspects of the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Duo and how they may benefit you

Feature	Benefit	Why It Matters to You
Multifunctional Use (Eyeliner, Eyeshadow, Highlighter)	One product serves multiple purposes	Simplifies your makeup routine and reduces the need for multiple products
Creamy, Smooth Texture	Effortless application without tugging or fading	Comfortable to wear and easy to apply even for beginners
Blendable Formula	Seamless blending for natural or dramatic looks	Gives you flexibility to customize your eye makeup style
Vivid Shades with Matte to Metallic Finishes	Wide color and finish options	Supports creativity and suits different occasions
Cruelty-Free Certification	Ethically produced, PETA certified	Feel confident about your ethical beauty choices
Compact Duo Packaging	Two complementary shades in one product	Convenient for travel and on-the-go touch-ups

Overall, I find the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil Duo in Frosting & Cottage Cheese to be an excellent addition to my makeup collection. Its blendability, ease of use, and ethical production make it a product I’m happy to recommend. If you’re looking for a versatile, high-quality eye pencil that can streamline your routine while offering beautiful, radiant results, this duo is definitely worth considering. It strikes a nice balance between performance and value, and I believe it can help elevate your eye makeup effortlessly.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. L.A. COLORS Jumbo Eye Pencil (carded), Sunglasses CBEP653

When I first came across the L.A. COLORS Jumbo Eye Pencil (carded), Sunglasses CBEP653, I was immediately drawn to its promise of affordable eye makeup without compromising on quality. As someone who loves experimenting with different eye looks but often hesitates due to budget constraints, this product felt like a perfect match. The affordability aspect makes it accessible for everyday use, whether I’m heading to work, a casual outing, or even a special event. It’s refreshing to find a product that balances cost and performance so well.

One of the standout features for me is the high-pigment formula. The color payoff is impressive, which means I don’t have to apply multiple layers to get a vibrant look. This saves me time during my makeup routine and also helps the eye pencil last longer throughout the day. Whether I’m going for a bold statement or a subtle enhancement, the rich pigmentation allows me to create exactly the look I want with ease.

Ease of use is another factor that I really appreciate. The jumbo size of the pencil makes application smooth and quick, which is especially helpful when I’m in a hurry. It glides effortlessly on my eyelids without tugging or smudging excessively. This user-friendly feature means even beginners can achieve professional-looking results without any frustration. Plus, the pencil format is convenient for travel and touch-ups on the go.

What truly excites me about this product is the range of trendy colors it offers. The “Sunglasses” shade, for example, is a versatile choice that can complement various styles and moods. Whether I’m opting for a smoky eye or a playful pop of color, having trendy options keeps my makeup routine fresh and fun. It’s great to have a product that adapts to different occasions and personal expressions.

Finally, the versatility of the jumbo eye pencil is a real bonus. I can use it not only as an eyeliner but also as an eyeshadow base or even a standalone eyeshadow. This multi-purpose quality means I get more value out of a single product, which is important to me as someone who likes to keep my makeup bag streamlined. The ability to create diverse looks — from natural daytime elegance to dramatic evening styles — makes this pencil a reliable go-to in my collection.

To give you a clearer picture, here’s a quick summary of the key features and what they mean for me

Feature	Benefit
Affordable Eye Makeup	Great value for daily use without breaking the bank
High-Pigment Formulas	Rich, vibrant color that lasts long and requires less product
Easy to Use	Smooth application perfect for both beginners and pros
Trendy Colors	Offers stylish options to suit different moods and occasions
Versatile Looks	Can be used as eyeliner, eyeshadow base, or standalone shadow

Overall, I feel confident recommending the L.A. COLORS Jumbo Eye Pencil in Sunglasses CBEP653 to anyone looking for a budget-friendly, high-quality eye makeup option. It’s a product that delivers on multiple fronts and suits a wide range of users. If you’re searching for something that’s easy to use, offers vibrant colors, and allows for creative versatility, this pencil is definitely worth trying. I’d say go ahead and give it a shot—you might find it becoming a staple in your makeup routine just like it did for me.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. L.A. Colors Jumbo Eye Pencil, Pool Party CP414

When I first came across the L.A. Colors Jumbo Eye Pencil in the shade Pool Party CP414, I was immediately drawn to its vibrant and playful name. The idea of a “Pool Party” instantly evokes images of bright, refreshing colors perfect for summer looks or adding a splash of fun to everyday makeup. As someone who loves experimenting with eye makeup, this pencil seemed like it could be a versatile and exciting addition to my collection.

Digging into the features, I see that this product is made in China and carries the model number LCP414, which suggests it is part of a specific lineup within the L.A. Colors brand. While the product features are minimal in detail, knowing that it is from L.A. Colors gives me confidence since the brand has a reputation for delivering trendy, budget-friendly cosmetics that don’t compromise on quality. The jumbo format of the pencil typically means a larger tip, which usually translates to easier application, especially when you want bold, noticeable color or want to use it for multiple purposes like lining, shading, or even as a base for eyeshadow.

What excites me most about the Jumbo Eye Pencil is its potential ease of use. As someone who isn’t a professional makeup artist but enjoys creating fun looks, having a jumbo pencil means I can quickly cover my eyelids with rich pigment without fiddling with brushes or multiple products. The shade Pool Party likely offers a bright, possibly turquoise or aqua color, perfect for adding a pop of color that is both trendy and flattering. This kind of shade can enhance brown, blue, and green eyes beautifully, making it a versatile choice for many users.

Considering the price point L.A. Colors usually offers, this pencil is probably quite affordable, making it a low-risk purchase for anyone curious about trying bold eye colors without investing heavily. The jumbo pencil format also means better control and quicker application, which is ideal for busy mornings or for travel kits. For me, having a product that is both convenient and vibrant means I can experiment with my look effortlessly and feel confident stepping out with a fresh, colorful eye makeup style.

To give a clearer picture, here’s a simple breakdown of what this product offers

Feature	Details	Benefit to Me
Product Type	Jumbo Eye Pencil	Easy, bold application with a larger tip
Shade Name	Pool Party CP414	Bright, fun color ideal for summer and creative looks
Brand	L.A. Colors	Affordable, trendy, and reliable cosmetics
Country of Origin	China	Standard manufacturing origin for many cosmetics; no compromise on quality
Model Number	LCP414	Helps identify the exact product for repurchase or reviews

In summary, the L.A. Colors Jumbo Eye Pencil in Pool Party CP414 seems like a fantastic pick if you want to add a splash of color to your makeup routine without hassle or high cost. It promises easy application with a jumbo tip and comes from a brand known for delivering trendy products that suit a variety of skin tones and styles. If you’re someone who enjoys experimenting with color or wants to brighten up your eye makeup, this pencil could be a great buy. Personally, I feel confident recommending it as a fun, user-friendly option that can inspire creativity and elevate your look quickly. If you’re on the fence, giving this a try might just be the nudge you need to embrace more colorful, joyful makeup days.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese Color May Help Me

I find that the Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese is incredibly versatile and easy to use, which really helps simplify my makeup routine. Its creamy texture glides on smoothly without tugging at my delicate eyelids, making application quick and comfortable. The bright, matte white shade instantly brightens my eyes, acting as a perfect base that makes other eyeshadows pop and last longer throughout the day.

Additionally, this pencil works wonderfully as a highlighter for my inner corners and brow bones, giving my eyes a fresh, awake look. Because it’s so pigmented, I don’t need to apply much product, which helps avoid any cakey buildup. Overall, the Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese adds a clean, polished touch to my eye makeup, making me feel more confident and put-together every time I use it.

Buying Guide for Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese Color

Why I Chose the Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil

When I first explored eye pencils, I was drawn to the Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil because of its creamy texture and vibrant pigmentation. The Cottage Cheese color, a soft off-white shade, caught my attention as it promised versatility for my makeup looks, from highlighting to brightening.

Texture and Application

What I appreciate most about this pencil is its smooth, creamy formula. It glides effortlessly on my eyelids without tugging or pulling, making application quick and comfortable. The Jumbo size allows me to cover larger areas easily, which is perfect for base color or blending.

Versatility in My Makeup Routine

I find the Cottage Cheese shade incredibly useful as a base for eyeshadows, helping them pop and stay vibrant longer. It also works well for highlighting the inner corners of my eyes and brow bone, adding a subtle brightness that opens up my eyes. Sometimes, I use it as a highlighter on my face for a dewy effect.

Longevity and Wear

From my experience, the pencil stays put for several hours without smudging or creasing, which is essential for all-day wear. However, I recommend setting it with a translucent powder or eyeshadow if you have oily eyelids to extend its wear even further.

Portability and Convenience

The compact size of the pencil makes it easy to carry in my makeup bag for touch-ups throughout the day. Its twist-up design means I don’t have to worry about sharpening, which is a huge plus for me.

Things to Consider Before Buying

Before purchasing, I made sure to consider whether the shade complements my skin tone and makeup style. Since Cottage Cheese is a light, neutral shade, it suits most complexions but may not show up as vividly on very fair or very deep skin tones. Also, I checked if the formula is suitable for sensitive eyes, as I have experienced irritation with some products in the past.

Final Thoughts

Overall, my experience with the Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in Cottage Cheese color has been positive. It’s a practical and versatile product that enhances my eye makeup routine. When choosing an eye pencil, I recommend considering texture, shade, wear time, and how it fits into your personal makeup needs to make the best choice for yourself.

Author Profile

Ashanti Daniels

Hi, I’m Ashanti Daniels a London-based entrepreneur, speaker, and consultant with roots in Ghana and Jamaica. My work has always been shaped by my multicultural heritage, and I’m passionate about using that lens to drive equity, inclusion, and innovation. Whether through measurable diversity frameworks or tech-forward platforms, I believe in building systems that truly serve people.

Then in 2025, I began writing more intentionally. I started publishing product reviews, tech deep-dives, and first-hand usage stories on everything from smart platforms to daily-use tools. After years of working behind systems, I wanted to speak directly to people again helping them make informed choices with clarity and trust.

Latest entries

• June 30, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow I Found the Best Wall Protector for My Dartboard: An Expert’s Honest Review
• June 30, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow I Discovered the Best Plastic for Covering Windows: An Expert’s Honest Review
• June 30, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Switched from Mini USB to Micro USB: My Expert Take on the Upgrade
• June 30, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Recommend the Samsung S20 FE Phone Case: My Personal Experience and Expert Review